Having launched its online shopping service in 2000, Asda recently overtook Sainsbury's to become the UK's second biggest online grocer.
Its online sales have been growing, but it still trails behind Tesco, with around 16.9% of the UK online grocery market compared with 31.3% for its rival, according to figures from July this year.
On most retail sites there are always areas which could be improved, so we've taken a look at the site from a customer experience perspective...
Sort out the shopping basket
If I go to the DVD section and choose a film to add to my basket, my basket will appear with a link to checkout. However, if I choose to return to the homepage, or visit another section of the site, my basket and its content are nowhere to be seen.
This must drive some customers mad, as it forces them to go through the process all over again. Or, alternatively, they may just leave the site. We wonder what kind of dropout rates Asda is seeing at the end of this journey.
Make the site fit the screen
The Asda website doesn't fit the whole screen, leaving roughly a third of the screen on the right totally blank.
Not only does this look bad, but it is also a waste of space above the fold. 95% of web users now have screen resolutions of 1024 or wider, so there is little reason not to widen the site. And if it doesn't, then centre-aligning it would look better, in my opinion.
Add an email signup option
Giving people the option of signing up to emails gives you an excellent way to build a relationship with customers, and will ultimately help to increase your sales.
Ideally, a link on the homepage should be provided, which Asda doesn't do. They could also offer the option on the registration page; if customers are entering email details anyway, why not ask them to subscribe?
Join up the different sections of the site
This is absolute madness: each section of the site is considered separate from the others so, if you begin shopping in the DVD section, add something to your basket, then decide to visit the Flowers section, all of your items will be lost.
This means that you need to register separately for each section of the site - this means that, if you want to buy a CD, some flowers, hay fever tablets and groceries in the one visit, you are forced to register four times. Absolute lunacy.
Altogether, the site is split into ten different sections, all requiring a unique login to make a purchase.
Word to Asda: sort this out and sales will rise. Care to take a performance-related wager with me?
Don't force shoppers to register before checkout
This isn't the case on all sections of the site, but for most you first need to enter address details, email, as well as telling Asda where you heard about the site.
This is placing unnecessary obstacles in front of prospective customers, who will have to enter their address details for delivery anyway. It makes no sense to do it this way around.
Improve product images
For products like CDs or DVD a basic image is all that's needed, but for more expensive products a range of angles is needed to help customers decide whether or not to buy.
With this sofa, many people would think twice about spending £1,000 when they can't even see how it looks from different angles. A basic picture is all that's offered here, while the zoom tool only enlarges the photo slightly.
Enclose the checkout
This is a common criticism I make of e-commerce sites. The idea behind enclosing the checkout is to focus the customer's mind by removing any distractions when they have reached the checkout.
This means that any links other than those that are essential to complete the purchase, such as returns policies, are removed. This also has the benefit of preventing customers from clicking outside the checkout and losing the information they have added up to that point.
Some checkouts have a different look and feel to the rest of the site, which can also focus the customer's mind on the purchase, but Asda does none of this with its checkout process.
The main navigation at the top of the screen stays in place, as well as links to customer services, sitemap etc at the bottom. I tried it out, and having entered my address details I could click back to the homepage and lose all the information I had entered.
This can be very frustrating for shoppers, and a few tweaks here could reduce Asda's abandonment rate.
Don't give me navigation links for products that don't exist
In the mobile phone section of the site, Asda has navigation links on the left for various makes of phone. However, click on LG or Motorola and you will not get any products at all:
Tell me about delivery costs on my shopping basket page
Shopping basket pages should provide a summary of the products a customer has added, the price, delivery details, and so on.
However, Asda's basket page is a bit too basic. The price is displayed, but delivery charges and times are nowhere to be seen, meaning that customers will need to go into the checkout process and enter address details before they can find this out.
As such, Asda may think it has a problem with the design of the checkout, if it has a higher than average abandonment rate, when in fact shoppers might simply be put off by Asda's delivery charges. Place this information on the product page and its checkout abandonment rate will appear to diminish.
Offer reassurances about site security
Some customers may have concerns about the security of their transaction, so signs that your website is trustworthy are essential to remove such doubts from customers' minds.
Unfortunately, with the exception of the grocery section, I found no third party security logos like VeriSign that could provide quick visual reassurance for customers.
There is some information on server security via a link at the bottom of the page, but this link does not stand out enough and could easily be missed.
Related articles:
10 things Currys can do better online
Q&A: Comet’s Content Manager Robbie Tutt
Graham Charlton is Senior Reporter at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter or connect via Linkedin.
11:06AM on 17th September 2008
Interesting post - it's incredible how poor some of the high street retailers websites are. While you've focused on conversion rate and usability here there's plenty they do wrong from an SEO perspective as well.
Out of interest though, why did you choose Asda? Plenty of the high street retailers make basic errors like this - seems strange to single them out?
Senior Reporter at Econsultancy
12:08PM on 17th September 2008
Hi Tom,
You're right, there are plenty of well known retailers that make such schoolboy errors with their websites. I didn't look at the SEO angle but I may do in future.
I didn't single out Asda for any particular reason, just noticed their site and the crazy registration situation. I have written similar articles on retailers; Next, M&S, Currys, and others.
Here's the Tesco one: http://www.e-consultancy.com/news-blog/365252/10-things-tesco-can-do-better-online.html
12:06PM on 18th September 2008
Good article! You have raised very good points there that is often times overlooked by ecommerce sites, big or small.
On a side note:
One thing the e-consultancy.com can do better - offer RSS links to subscribe to the blog. :-)
Keep up the good work.
10:00AM on 24th September 2008
FYI - I just wrote a post about the seo failings of the uk highstreet retailers and gave a link back to your story.
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/the-seo-failings-of-major-uk-highstreet-retailers
Thanks
Tom
11:14AM on 24th September 2008
Great analysis. Its quite amazing what goes on with these large corporate websites.