1. Ben Seaman Bronze

    Sales at Sales

    26 June 2009 21:30pm

    Avatar-blank-50x50

    Hello! my first post here. I did search for this topic but couldn't find an answer.

    We are redesigning our retail store homepage:

    Which is best

    Horizontal navigation (like www.gaiam.com)

    or

    Vertical navigation (like www.Gardeners.com)

    or

    a combination of both?

     

    We will have a similar number of categories as Gardeners.com (Gaiam has many more categories).

    Our current store is here, built by my father and I: http://eartheasy.com/shop.htm  We're going to redo this using Magento.

    Thanks SO much for advice on this topic.

     

     

     

     

  2. Adam Shallcross

    Director at The CogWorks

    28 June 2009 08:09am

    Adam Shallcross

    It really depends on how many top-level and level 2 categories you have really.

    There is no right or wrong answer.

    If you can fit all your top level categories along the top, then you can use the vertical nav for the sub categories, thereby drawing the customers eye to the top of the screen.

    However, looking at your current site, you top level category names seem quite long, so you could maybe use the top nav for administration purposes such as login, account admin, shopping basket info etc and place all your categories in the vertical nav.

    I wouldn't have all your categories listed out though as on http://www.gardeners.com/ becuase it is a little too long. I would just list out the main top-level ones as on http://www.amazon.co.uk/ so all your info is above the fold line of the screen. This will ensure your customers dont miss any of your products.

    You can then either use an accordian styles menu that shows the sub categories when you click into it, or a JavaScript/CSS style menu as on Amazon.  The choice is yours really.

    Just ensure it is built in such a way that if style and JavaScript is turned off it can stil be seen i.e. <ul><li>menu item<li></ul>

    I hope that helps

    Adam

    www.thecogworks.co.uk

  3. steve johnson Bronze

    Retail conusltant at Retail-Remedy

    05 July 2009 03:28am

    steve johnson

    As per your choice you can then either use an accordian styles menu that shows the sub categories when you click into it, or a JavaScript/CSS style menu as on other shopping or ecommerce sites. Click on retail layout page here you get the good style.

  4. Ben Seaman Bronze

    Sales at Sales

    07 July 2009 01:21am

    Avatar-blank-50x50

    Ok, great. Thank you Adam for the time you put into answering us. We'll likely do the accordian style nav w. javascript on the left. Thanks again.

  5. Rob Smith Silver

    Strategy Director at Blueleaf

    08 July 2009 14:28pm

    Rob Smith

    I'd go for the vertical navigation with those labels you have now - especially if you are planning to leave the learn, shop, etc aspects across the top as well.

    With Magento, I would make sure that you know someone or seek someone out who knows Magento quite well as although it does a lot of things very well, our experience is that if you want to change anything too much you have to dig quite deep and so some experience can help

Reply to this thread

Log in to reply to this thread or join Econsultancy for free so you can post to our forums along with other benefits.