1. James Radcliffe

    Pro Retail

    28 October 2008 14:51pm

    James Radcliffe

    Hi, wonder if any search experts can help with this one.

    Our site has a credit at the foot of each page linking to our web design agency. We agreed this at the start of the project and they gave us a big discount on the job as they wanted us on their client list so I'm not worried about the ethics or commercial asepcts of this.

    Our problem is  that another SEO consultant has now come along and said this is affecting our rankings, something about watering down our internal links.

    It's not something that I can find any reference to in Google's guidelines, is it something I should be worried about? I dont know who to beleive!

  2. dan barker

    E-Business Consultant at Dan Barker

    28 October 2008 15:21pm

    dan barker

    hi, James, I wouldn't be too worried.

    Your SEO's idea will probably be based around this (using the homepage as an example):

    1. Your homepage has a certain amount of links coming into it. In Google's eyes this gives your homepage a certain amount of 'voting rights' - ie. the ability to link out to other pages & give them some trust in google.
    2. Your homepage is linking out to 3 pages.
    3. From 2 of those links, you benefit personally (you are passing trust across to your own pages).
    4. From the 3rd, your design company benefits, but you don't.
    5. Therefore, you are only giving 66% of your 'voting rights' to your own pages.

    This is a very hazy area & there are always questions on whether sitewide links transfer as much trust, etc. I think as long as your design agency is reputable, I wouldn't worry too much about it.

    If you are concerned, get in touch with them & ask if they mind you switching their link to a 'nofollow' link. A nofollow says to Google "I'm linking to this site, but I don't want to allot any trust to it".

    Hope that's useful.

    daniel

  3. Denis Kondopoulos

    Technical Project Manager (MBA, MBCS, CITP, CEng) at Naxtech.com

    28 October 2008 15:26pm

    Denis Kondopoulos

    Hi James,

    in theory having an irrelevant link (ie. link to a supplier/designer) at the very bottom of a page does not necessarily provide any benefit to your website seo-wise.  However, from my experience I would not say that having that link is something to worry about nor would it make a huge difference to your SEO performance.  

    Even if it does affect your site seo-wise there are still ways to keep the link there without it having an seo-related effect to your site.

    I hope this helps.

    regards,

    Denis
    www.naxtech.com

  4. Ed Stivala

    Managing Director at n3w media

    29 October 2008 07:30am

    Ed Stivala

    Hello James,

    I would be more worried about your SEO company to be honest! Having a footer link back to your design agency is pretty common practice and really is not likely to cause you any problems with regard to how your site ranks in search engines.

    What would concern me more is that a company that purports to be able to help you with search marketing has suggested to you that it is an issue...

    Kind Regards

    Ed
    http://www.n3wmedia.com

  5. dan barker

    E-Business Consultant at Dan Barker

    29 October 2008 09:17am

    dan barker

    hi, Eddie,

    you're right - having a sitewide link back to a design company is common practice. I don't think it's worth starting a witchhunt against the SEO though - I'd be far more surprised if they hadn't mentioned this as something to bear in mind.

    daniel

  6. James Radcliffe

    Pro Retail

    29 October 2008 11:27am

    James Radcliffe

    Thanks all,

    Actually our design guys came back to us with the nofollow thing as a suggestion yesterday which looks like it's endorsed here.

    Interesting comments though and much appreciated

Reply to this thread

Log in to reply to this thread or join Econsultancy for free so you can post to our forums along with other benefits.