1. Alex Judd Bronze

    Director at Skywire

    09 May 2001 16:06pm

    Alex Judd

    To be fair to GPRS technology, it has managed to avoid the excessive hype that surrounded the launch of WAP networks - there has been little promise to deliver the world Internet on their telephones, the excessive claims of it's speed increases were managed since conception and technology trials kept small enough to manage expectations of the users and developers testing the technology.

    However as one of the current 25 Beta testers for BTCellnet's GPRS network I personally have serious issues over the defined purposes of GPRS technology versus it's current incarnation and just how much it will manage to bridge the gap between today's 2G networks and the distant future launch of 3G networks.

    Let's start with the basics - the ability to remain 'always-on' and to deliver packet based data. In theory this sounds fantastic, users can simply delve into the world of online information at any point they need to and grab out useful snippets of information such as train times, today's weather and the headlines.

    However in reality the actual operation forces the user to abandon all other phone functions (such as essential ones like 'phone book' and 'voice calls') in order to access a seperate section of the phone device and to then wait considerable amounts of time for the device to establish the connection to its APN (Access Point Name) (I would argue it is longer than WAP connection times).

    Now I agree this may be to do with the current phone design, but that's another of my issues. The only GPRS devices available today are the, to be frankly honest, the non-userfriendly designed Motorola TimePort GRPS devices which are not only currently in short supply due to Motorola's financial difficulties in the UK but are also difficult to use as WAP devices. Trying to configure one of these GPRS devices to use the IP based GPRS networks of is at best frustrating for the experienced wireless developers that I work with, so the reliability of the 2.5G user base configuring these correctly is not going to be high.

    This coupled with Orange's recent accouncement of a delay to the role of their GPRS services and BTCellnet's frankly painfull press launch of their services (note to Cellnet: must remember that too many GPRS phones on single cell uses up all available bandwidth) the role out of GPRS in my opinion will be slow, patchy and will be hopefully steamrollered by the emerging 3G networks going into build and test at the moment.

    I personally believe in the wireless internet as being one of the leading lights in the next few years, however all of the players in the market are going to need to smarten up their act to make it happen in a way that will encourage the mobile user base to take the services seriously. With a good network, good phone design and of course killer services - the mobile Internet will provide what most of the WAP adverts promised 18 months ago, however GPRS looks like providing another round of headaches rather than solutions for it's users.

    Alex

    Skywire Wireless Solutions
    providers of bespoke wireless consultancy and service development

  2. Ketan Bhatt Bronze

    Senior Consultant at Consultancy

    23 May 2001 18:01pm

    Ketan Bhatt

    I am seeking to join an organisation in developing new products and solutions within this market sector encompassing technologies of 3G / GPRS / Bluetooth. If any of the members are aware of any exciting opportunities, could you please e-mail me at .

    On 16:06:53 9 May 2001 Alex wrote:
    >To be fair to GPRS technology, it has managed to avoid the
    >excessive hype that surrounded the launch of WAP networks
    >- there has been little promise to deliver the world
    >Internet on their telephones, the excessive claims of it's
    >speed increases were managed since conception and
    >technology trials kept small enough to manage expectations
    >of the users and developers testing the technology.
    >
    >However as one of the current 25 Beta testers for
    >BTCellnet's GPRS network I personally have serious issues
    >over the defined purposes of GPRS technology versus it's
    >current incarnation and just how much it will manage to
    >bridge the gap between today's 2G networks and the distant
    >future launch of 3G networks.
    >
    >Let's start with the basics - the ability to remain
    >'always-on' and to deliver packet based data. In theory
    >this sounds fantastic, users can simply delve into the
    >world of online information at any point they need to and
    >grab out useful snippets of information such as train
    >times, today's weather and the headlines.
    >
    >However in reality the actual operation forces the user to
    >abandon all other phone functions (such as essential ones
    >like 'phone book' and 'voice calls') in order to access a
    >seperate section of the phone device and to then wait
    >considerable amounts of time for the device to establish
    >the connection to its APN (Access Point Name) (I would
    >argue it is longer than WAP connection times).
    >
    >Now I agree this may be to do with the current phone
    >design, but that's another of my issues. The only GPRS
    >devices available today are the, to be frankly honest, the
    >non-userfriendly designed Motorola TimePort GRPS devices
    >which are not only currently in short supply due to
    >Motorola's financial difficulties in the UK but are also
    >difficult to use as WAP devices. Trying to configure one
    >of these GPRS devices to use the IP based GPRS networks of
    >is at best frustrating for the experienced wireless
    >developers that I work with, so the reliability of the
    >2.5G user base configuring these correctly is not going to
    >be high.
    >
    >This coupled with Orange's recent accouncement of a delay
    >to the role of their GPRS services and BTCellnet's frankly
    >painfull press launch of their services (note to Cellnet:
    >must remember that too many GPRS phones on single cell
    >uses up all available bandwidth) the role out of GPRS in
    >my opinion will be slow, patchy and will be hopefully
    >steamrollered by the emerging 3G networks going into build
    >and test at the moment.
    >
    >I personally believe in the wireless internet as being one
    >of the leading lights in the next few years, however all
    >of the players in the market are going to need to smarten
    >up their act to make it happen in a way that will
    >encourage the mobile user base to take the services
    >seriously. With a good network, good phone design and of
    >course killer services - the mobile Internet will provide
    >what most of the WAP adverts promised 18 months ago,
    >however GPRS looks like providing another round of
    >headaches rather than solutions for it's users.
    >
    >Alex
    >
    >Skywire Wireless Solutions
    >providers of bespoke wireless consultancy and service
    >development

Reply to this thread

Log in to reply to this thread or join Econsultancy for free so you can post to our forums along with other benefits.