The Beatles once sang, "All you need is love" and thanks to the rise of social media, it's not just humans looking for it. Brands, once largely relegated to communicating with consumers through one-way mediums like television and radio, have flocked to services like Facebook and Twitter in search of long-term relationships.

If the millions of 'Likes' and followers some of them have attracted are any indication, social media could be the foundation of a happy marriage between brands and consumers. But under the surface, this relationship may not be as solid as it appears.

According to Gartner, brands are increasingly turning to paying for positive reviews, 'Likes' and followers on popular social networking sites and by 2014, the research firm estimates that over one in ten of these will be fake.

Gartner is predicting that within the next two years, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) will be forced to take action, and that at least two Fortune 500 brands will face litigation over their shady social tactics.

According to Gartner VP Ed Thompson, brands are at a crossroads and CMOs "will need to weigh the longer-term risks of being caught and the associated fines and damage to reputation and balance them against the short-term potential rewards of increased business and the prevailing common business practice in their market, often regardless of ethics."

It's so easy

As Ryan Skinner, AD of B2B marketing agency Velocity, pointed out in a guest blog post here on Econsultancy, "Finding a vendor who will sell you followers or likes is easier than googling 'buy facebook likes.'" With such an active, accessible trade in fake social actions and followers, it's not entirely surprising that some marketers decide to take the plunge.

And why shouldn't they? The metrics by which social success is often measured are not always so easy to grow organically, but they're cheap to manipulate. And a marketer looking for a reason to indulge in that manipulation can easily justify questionable tactics: the more [insert social media metric here] I have, the more legitimate ones I'll attract.

Are Facebook and Twitter to blame?

Of course, most of instinctively know that followers and 'Likes' probably aren't the best metrics by which to measure social success. In fact, most of us accept that they're probably more akin to clicks than they are to conversions.

So why are we so focused on metrics that are often so flawed? There are several reasons:

In short, many marketers put themselves in a position where they're almost entirely dependent on the Facebooks and Twitters of the world. Instead of taking their analysis to the next level by correlating performance against important business KPIs, they use the limited and often flawed metrics they're given.

To be fair to companies like Facebook, helping marketers establish that ROI exists is a top priority, but marketers should remember: the goal of that exercise is, for Facebook, to sell more ads. Caveat emptor still applies.

You're not fooling anybody

So where does this leave marketers debating whether or not to cook the books? It's worth considering that the only ones fooled by online love-buying are the marketers engaging in the tactic.

A timely case in point: American wireless carrier AT&T won the battle for the most 'likeable' ads during the summer Olympics this year, but in the past two year it has ranked in last place for customer satisfaction. The lesson: likeable ads, lots of followers and more 'Likes' than you can count in a year are nice, but when it comes to earning an individual's business and keeping it, trust, respect and satisfaction are far more important. And you can't purchase those.

Patricio Robles

Published 18 September, 2012 by Patricio Robles

Patricio Robles is a tech reporter at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter.

2647 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (5)


Adi Gaskell

I'm surprised this figure isn't higher. Whilst likes and followers are fairly useless in terms of generating business, plenty of research has shown how important reviews are for business.

For instance a study by the University of California @ Berkely earlier this month showed that an increase of just 0.5 stars (in a 5 star scale) meant a restaurant was 20% more likely to sell out their tables than the ones with the lower rating.

There's a clear temptation to cook the books, especially with Google investing so much in G+ Local.

almost 6 years ago


Kat Rags

I can't say I'm too surprised! As a content provider, I've often been paid to write reviews of products I've never even tried! It presents an interesting problem to those of us trying to market our businesses online. Do we include product reviews on our website? How do we make them appear credible? As for social media, that is another big content 'job.' Most of my larger clients request I keep track of their social media and this often means posting responses. Is there an ethical issue here?

almost 6 years ago



Interesting? How do you draw the line? There is no distinction between friends and business on many social networking sites.

almost 6 years ago


Matt Lovell, Head of Customer Data, Insight & Analytics at Eurostar International Ltd.

Interesting article. I'm intrigued by the 'Are Facebook and Twitter to blame' element too as to an extent I think they are:-

Both are incredibly restrictive in terms of what they will and won't allow you to track through 3rdf party tracking in terms of likes, follows, comments and engagments so with so little that advertisers can link directly back to on site engagements that advertisers aren't left with much else!

almost 6 years ago



Believe me, buying or paying for "Likes" and "Followers" won't last longer. People sooner or later will know it. In fact, some of my customers don't want to use Facebook to generate sales but give genuine customer support. With genuine customer support on Facebook and Twitter, it helps in getting real Likes, Followers and sales.

Modern marketers just make the world complicated.

almost 6 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.