Digital marketer Steve Rubel has an interesting post entitled "Three Internet Careers That Soon Won't Exist" in which he predicts that social media managers, internet advertising salespeople and digital talent agents will see their jobs disappear as the tasks they perform are "integrated into other roles."

Interestingly, he also notes that "jobs in Web 2.0 are way off their peak" and that shows a "steep decline in listings that mention social networking, Web 2.0, Ajax and blogs."

But I wasn't particularly interested in Rubel's post because of its premise. I was interested in the flaws in the details.

Rubel states:

"The web has finally become the dominant marketing and media platform and where everyone is largely focusing their resources."

I found this to be quite interesting. There's no doubt that the internet is the focus of quite a bit of attention. After all, it is the new kid on the block.

But currently the internet accounts for less than 10% of ad spending in the United States and a little more than 20% of consumption time.

Television, on the other hand, accounts for around 40% of ad spending and about the same percentage of consumption time.

A commenter on Rubel's blog pointed out a number of other facts that deserve attention:

  • 80% of the world is not connected.
  • More than half of global internet users don't have broadband internet access.
  • For many businesses, offline advertising drives considerable increases in their online performance, highlighting just how powerful offline advertising can still be.

Throw in the fact that internet advertising isn't perfect and that it has been established that the people who are clicking on your internet ads probably aren't the people you want clicking on them, and it's quite premature to call the internet today's "dominant marketing and media platform."

What this demonstrates is the level to which the hype has blinded even ostensibly intelligent people to the fact that, when looked at in perspective, despite the internet's rise, there's still much more to the marketing and media landscape.

Is the internet important? Yes. Does it play a prominent role in the marketing and media landscape? Absolutely.

Because of this, I don't necessarily disagree with Rubel's argument that "everyone will be expected to know how to navigate the online landscape if they want to have a thriving career".

Being able to "navigate the online landscape" has different implications for different professions but it would be naive to assume that workers can thrive without an ability to leverage the online tools relevant to their professions.

But at the same time, amidst all the hype, I think an important fact is being overlooked - to thrive, you still have to know how to navigate the offline landscape.

After all, even though it may not be as sexy as the online landscape, it's still just as important, if not more important.

Especially in a world where integrated marketing and media is most likely to be the most effective methodology for reaching consumers effectively.

Given how much emphasis has been placed on the internet at the expense of less-hyped yet still-powerful media and the fact that younger generations of workers are naturally comfortable with the online landscape, it would not be surprising to see an ironic twist.

Employers may eventually place more value on workers who can also navigate the offline landscape because workers who can navigate the online landscape will be a dime a dozen.

Drama 2.0

Published 26 March, 2008 by Drama 2.0

237 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (2)

Alan Charlesworth

Alan Charlesworth, lecturer / researcher at University of Sunderland

Totally agree with your analysis, and would add that "social networking, Web 2.0, Ajax and blogs" are more about consumers than sellers, so there has/will never be a great demand for folk working in those environments [how many 'corporate blog writers' do you know?].

As you say - 'online' will become [has become?] an integral element of both strategic and operational marketing - but there will always be a place for specialists - as traditionally there has always been for market research, buyer behaviour, communications, advertising, sponsorship and all the other elements of the marketing and promotional mixes.

At least I hope there will be or I'll be out of work - and I have an expensive wife and mortgage to maintain.

over 10 years ago


Richard Mathis, teacher at college

Great post. The Internet is a great thing that we can use to achieve results. It can be used for different goals. For example, you want to find a job. You need a great resume (you always can get help ) If you have a particular activity on the Internet, you should include it in the resume. For example, you have your own blog and people who read it. This will show your expertise and that you are interesting for people. Use all your opportunities to represent yourself. The more you use opportunities, the more chances you have to get the job.

over 1 year ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.