Services like Digg have become an important tool in the arsenal of online publishers. After all, they're capable of spreading an article or blog post virally, resulting in tons of traffic in very short order.

Quite a few blogs, for instance, which I won't mention, are known to receive a lot of their traffic thanks to the fact that their stories frequently hit the Digg front page.

Whether or not this is done as part of a concerted effort to 'game the system' is often a tricky question to answer.

But in the case of one online publisher that just so happens to also be a traditional publisher, it appears that 'gaming the system' is precisely the strategy.

Village Voice Media is "the largest group of metropolitan newsweeklies in the U.S." and according to blogger Ed Kohler, Village Voice Media has been using (and abusing?) Digg to drive tons of traffic to its websites.

In an great example of the type of research and investigation bloggers are capable of, he presents a compelling case that a handful of Digg users, all employed or somehow associated with Village Voice Media, are responsible for the company's success in getting onto Digg's front page.

Kohler became interested in the subject after reading an article about's massive traffic growth. is the site for Village Voice Media’s Minnesota newsweekly. In October, its Blotter blog had only 35,000 pageviews. By December that increased to 250,000. Given that Kohler saw only 100 Google Reader subscribers for this blog, he became suspicious. You don't grow pageviews seven-fold in a two month time organically when you only have 100 Google Reader subscribers.

Kohler's post is well worth the read but at the end he addresses the topic that I think is most worth discussing here: if Village Voice Media is gaming Digg and selling traffic advertising against its Digg traffic, is Village Voice Media also gaming advertisers?

In the past, he has noted that Digg users don't seem to click on ads and points to another post detailing a similar observation. While I'm sure this topic could be the subject of much debate, the bottom line is that it appears Village Voice Media gets a non-negligible amount of its traffic from Digg. Depending on how much, it's possible that Village Voice Media's traffic is not only not organic, but also a bit homogeneous.

These are two facts that advertisers would probably be interested to learn. But is Village Voice Media telling them where most of its traffic is coming from and are advertisers asking?

Probably not. I certainly wouldn't expect Village Voice Media to eagerly promote the fact that a lot of its traffic appears to be coming from a service like Digg, which highlights the fact that there are real risks for less sophisticated advertisers who don't ask detailed questions.

But this also creates an opportunity for online publishers. Being willing and able to provide more quantitative and qualitative data about your traffic and users can be a great sales tool in this economic environment. It also gives you the opportunity to be of real value to advertisers by providing some free education.

If I was competing with Village Voice Media, for instance, and was pursuing an advertiser I knew to be dealing with the company, I wouldn't hesitate to discuss their reliance on traffic from Digg and to educate the user about the risks of advertising on properties with homogeneous, non-organic traffic.

While it's nice to grow traffic exponentially overnight, in my opinion gaming social media is hardly the foundation for a thriving and sustainable online property.

Looking at it this way, perhaps the question is not whether Village Voice Media is doing something unethical but rather "Where are my competitors getting their traffic?" If they're gaming the system, you just might be able to checkmate them when it comes to the game that counts: winning over the advertisers you both compete for.

Patricio Robles

Published 9 February, 2009 by Patricio Robles

Patricio Robles is a tech reporter at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter.

2642 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (3)



How are they gaming Digg?  It takes an awful lot more than a handful of employees digging something for content to go popular.  That traffic from Digg doesn't convert very well is not really news.  By all means raise the issue of proberty amongst advertisers, especially the CPM kind, but to suggest that this company is gaming Digg is kinda sensationalist.

over 9 years ago


Ed Kohler

Adi, it may not be news to you to hear that traffic from Digg doesn't convert well. But,  local busiensses are often under the impression that buying ads with a local media site, like your local VVM property, will generate impressions among a local audience. My point of the post was to show that Village Voice Media is actively driving non-local traffic to local business' ads. If VVM is making money off local businesses by showing Digg users to their ads, there's a problem, as you understand.

And, yes, there are more people involved than I named in the story. The ones I identified are the power users in their network along with a few further down the food chain.

over 9 years ago

Patricio Robles

Patricio Robles, Tech Reporter at Econsultancy

Adi - oftentimes you don't need more than a handful of influential users on sites like Digg to 'game the system'. When you have a few power users like Village Voice Media appears to have, you can accomplish a lot.

over 9 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.