American iPhone users have been quietly biding their time until Apple ends its exclusive contract with AT&T, hoping for better service, cheaper phones and lower monthly bills. But if the iPhone situation across the pond serves any example, those things aren't likely to happen any time soon.

Starting January 14, Vodafone is set to start selling iPhones in the U.K. But the company's cheapest deal will end up being more expensive over the lifetime of the device than anything currently offered to iPhone users. That's bad news for consumers who expected a little competition would make the iPhone more accessible to users.

O2's exclusive contract to sell the iPhone in the U.K. ended in November. The difference betwen O2's prices and those at Orange, who also now sells the iPhone, is only 84p.

Forced to wait until January to start selling the smartphones, Vodafone has missed out on the Christmas rush. And the company is not planning to undercut its rivals to win customers. According to The Telegraph, Vodafone’s cheapest offer will cost £899 over the life of the phone, more than both O2 and Orange, the company that started selling iPhones in November. And while competitors like super market chain Tesco offer plans for as litle as £20 a month, the headset costs £320 to purchase upfront.

But even if Tesco really undercut the phone companies, many consumers are still willing to pay for connectivity stability. Like AT&T in the U.S., Britain's O2 has had data issues, including two crashes in recent months that left users unable to make calls or connect to the Internet.

And that's really where the issue hits home in the U.S. As Saturday Night Live noted this week, it's commonly agreed that the iPhone gets terrible phone service:

Verizon has been happily running ads touting the failures of AT&T's 3G data coverage, but it looks like AT&T may not be so bad after all. According to Gizmodo, AT&T has the best 3G service out of any national providers here. That's bad news for consumers hoping another provider would be able to support the phone better.

This gets to the unfortunate reality that as more carriers start offering the iPhone, they might offer fewer subsidies, instead of more. Which means that the iPhone could cost closer to its $600 street value than the $199 that AT&T currently offers it for.

As users become more device loyal than network focused, it doesn't make sense for carriers to eat headset costs. They already have to tie consumers into lengthy contracts to guarantee they will recoup headset costs with monthly charges. But once consumers have finished their contract (and often before), they're off in search of the newest, most exciting device.

Another option is to make contracts excessively long, which could guide users into paying exit fees more often to get a new phone. In Europe, where iPhone contracts run 2.6 years, that option doesn't sound so far fetched. But either way, this is not exciting news for consumers hoping to pay less for an iPhone in the near future.

A more likely way for the iPhone to get cheaper is through smartphone competition. If Google can sell the Android for significantly less money, it would be in Apple's best interest to subsidize the price of its handset instead of waiting for phone carriers to do it.

Image: CNET UK

Meghan Keane

Published 22 December, 2009 by Meghan Keane

Based in New York, Meghan Keane is US Editor of Econsultancy. You can follow her on Twitter: @keanesian.

721 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (4)


Nigel Sarbutts

There is a significant flaw with Iphones on the Orange network. They keep re-setting to the wrong outgoing server port so you can't send or reply to emails, other by deleting your account and re-inputting all the account details.

Orange currently cannot give a date when they will have a fix for this.

over 8 years ago


oh , i hope it will be cheaper and cheaper and then to buy one,LOL~~~

over 8 years ago


Peter Brooks

You can also get iPhone for free now if you live in the UK,USA or Canada here:

over 8 years ago



haha they have got some great apps out there. what are your favorite apps?

over 8 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.