Facebook has gotten a lot of flack for its misdirected contextual advertising. Advertisers on the site have access to personal demographic data, and they don't always use it wisely. (Hello free laptop offers that randomly use age and location data!)

Poorly targeted ads are bad for Facebook's fledgling ad products, and the company has announced that it will start cracking down on demographic data abusers. Today, ClickZ has some details on Facebook's plans. Marketers may not be exciting to see what the social network is getting rid of, but Facebook is keeping an eye on its longterm business model.

Facebook's innovative self-service platform might be bringing in a lot of money, but showing consumers poorly targeted ads is bad for business. As The New York Times recently wrote:

"On social networks like Facebook, where people go to communicate with one another, advertisers seem to be trying especially hard to intrude on the conversation."

Facebook is aware of the problem and now has an evaluation program designed to seek out and discard ads that utilize user data that is not relevant to the product on offer. The new process will be part digitized and part human.

Facebook is still keen to have well-targeted ads on its site, but aggressive marketers targeting users with irrelevant ad copy are going to feel the hurt. According to ClickZ:

"Ads that are legitimately either locally targeted, gender-specific, or aimed at an age demo will apparently not get struck down while going after those audience segments. However, ads submitted with arbitrary profile-based copy - such as "37 and male in Los Angeles?" - have been met with rejection, some marketers say. A similar system is being used to weed out ads that incentivize a click-through (e.g., "Get A Free Laptop!") but do not deliver on the promise for several pages - if ever."

This makes a lot of sense for the social network, as ads on the site need to be relevant to grow in value. The new changes won't affect large brands advertising on the social network, but they will have a negative impact on smaller advertisers, who find that these tactics work pretty well.

Dan Sommer, CEO of Caridan Marketing Labs, tells ClickZ:

"If I can call out [in an ad] that you are a male in New York, that is a major driver for click-through rates. Because they are not allowing that anymore, [the ads] are going to be a little bit less engaging and relevant."

But if a product is actually relevant to a user's age and location, it will still make it through Facebook's system. And for consumers to start paying attention to the little Facebook ads on their pages, they have to be consistently pertinent. 

As I noted earlier this month, consumers easily tune out advertising online, and irrelevant ads on Facebook encourage that behavior.

The problem of course is that self-serve ads are part of why Facebook is expected to bring in $1.1 billion in revenue this year. Turning away small advertisers could have a negative impact on the company's bottom line this year. But if Facebook wants to deliver on its promise of relevant social ads, it needs to help advertisers create useful ads. And this is a step in that direction.

Image: Facebook

Meghan Keane

Published 22 March, 2010 by Meghan Keane

Based in New York, Meghan Keane is US Editor of Econsultancy. You can follow her on Twitter: @keanesian.

721 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (1)


Paul Manning

GPSLocals.com “ The Holy Grail” for advertisers……………

The key to all this, said Paul Manning ( Chairman GPSLocals), was to offer a low cost solution to meet today’s marketing budgets of struggling businesses and combine it with the latest technology used by consumers. The recent information in the Berg-insight report about GPS devices clearly states to business owners that more and more potential customers are using GPS as a method of locating addresses.

Perhaps this is why McDonalds, Exxon, MasterCard and a whole bunch of others are turning to GPS for “search marketing”.

Global shipments of GPS-enabled handsets increased by 92% in 2009 to 150 million units and further forecasted to reach 770 million units in 2014.

How will this help small independent outlets?

GPS Locals provides a facility for any size organization or outlet to get listed next to, and sometimes above the “big boys”, as the results are given in distance order.

Whilst end users download or access MasterCard ATM’s, McDonalds, Exxon Stations etc, they also receive information about smaller outlets that have listed.

For any size establishments to be found they need to submit their name and contact details including products & services, this can then be searched for on GPS and GPS Locals own on-line search engine.

There is an annual administration fee of just 10 Euro’s with no fees for the end user.

The listed establishments can then be searched for and found by millions of users.

I look forward to receiving your views,

over 8 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.