Panda 4.1, as it has been dubbed, was released by Google last week with the aim of identifying low quality content more easily. 

According to Google, it affects between 3% and 5% of search queries and will result 'in a greater diversity of high-quality small- and medium-sized sites ranking higher'. 

I asked Marcus Tober, CTO and co-founder of SearchMetrics, about the new update. 

What is Google aiming to achieve with Panda 4.1?

Google’s Panda updates are always aiming for quality enhancement of the search engine results.

The first Panda update was known as the content farm update, because it was mainly directed against thin content that was placed on large scale platforms such as ehow or

Panda 4.0 was a major rework of the whole Panda implementation in the algorithm. So Panda 4.1 is just the continuation of what Google did with 4.0.

Where are you seeing the biggest changes so far?

You can see that a Panda update was rolled out just on our list of winners and losers. There is always a pattern on the sites on these lists.

Panda updates are query based. That means that the impact is not on all queries, only a specific set of queries and that’s why you can find a pattern. The changes we saw this time are again directed against a lot of thin content and aggregator sites.

Sites like FindTheBest, Pearltrees or aggregate content and present it in a nice, easy-to-consume way.

But they are aggregators which means no unique content and it's also aggregated like a search engine. And Google doesn’t want search-in-search to rank highly.

Based on what you have seen so far, has Panda 4.1 achieved what Google wanted?

This is a question that only Google can answer. Google is never finished.

Every new iteration of Panda or other updates will increase the quality. But with all the redundancy in the World Wide Web, Google has a lot to do to filter out the noise and increase the relevancy of the results step by step.

What kinds of signals does Google look for to determine low-quality, thin content sites and pages?

There are two different kind of signals. Quantitative signals are based on content and site structure. Qualitative signals are based on user behavior.

For the quantitive signals it is Google’s mission to find sites with unique and rich content. Content with an added value for the user. And with all the data that Google has, it is the next step to take the user signals and weight the results against a group of other results.

Results with worse than average user behavior are sites with a bad user experience. Google is using both signals to determine which results are relevant for the user based on their query.

When a site has too many 'bad' signals, the whole site can be dropped out of the rankings. Panda is not just based on some keywords on a website. It always hits a huge part of the page, that’s why Panda is a serious issue. 

What is your advice for sites hit by Panda?

Housekeeping! Many sites just have too much thin content. They have to add value to these pages, find redundant pages and merge them or just delete them if it’s old outdated content.

But importantly, if you don’t do anything it will get worse. These pages that just keep their thin content will have the so called slow-death phenomenon.

They gradually lose visibility over time until nothing is left. That’s why companies should build a Panda proof site before they are affected.

What do you think Google will be looking to deal with in the next update?

Google always wants to improve and to deliver the right result for the right time in the right context.

There will be many more updates where content relevancy will be the key. 

Graham Charlton

Published 1 October, 2014 by Graham Charlton

Graham Charlton is editor in chief at SaleCycle, and former editor at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter or connect via Linkedin.

2566 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (9)

Save or Cancel


Hi, thanks for this post :)

Can you elaborate on what you meant by this statement:

"... It always hits a huge part of the page ..."?

almost 4 years ago



Great post, thanks.

Regarding the thin content element of the update - any thoughts if eCommerce sites (or just the product pages with thin content) will suffer more now? Or does Google recognise an eCommerce site, and perhaps apply a different rule to the algo?

almost 4 years ago

Graham Charlton

Graham Charlton, Editor in Chief at SaleCycle

@Drew I think Marcus means that Panda studies a lot of signals around a specific webpage, not just a few keywords.

almost 4 years ago


Carl Ebanks

It's clear Google have yet to do anything in the woeful careers sector where Indeed seem to dominate the rankings on most queries, often times multiple times on page one, due to layered geo-targeted results.

For example: returns Indeed in the top 4 positions.

almost 4 years ago

Daniel Lee

Daniel Lee, Web Analytics Manager at Evans Cycles

A good update.

I look forward to seeing how this shakes up SERPs.

almost 4 years ago



Agreed ^^ a good update - keep em coming think n fast hay! at least she is alive and kicking again, 2013 saw barely any updates - 2014 kicking out per quarter...

A sad Pandas got to eat zz n thin content tastes sooo good.

Off to find some more long tail eerrrmmm 'conversion minded' keywords I mean.


almost 4 years ago



Here is an interesting Infographic and history of Google Panda:

almost 4 years ago



Good information and this is the time when Penguin refersh is also supposed to release soon, marketers will need to analyze their website content, structure and back-links to come over the poor things.

almost 4 years ago



My site has unfortunately erwicht but I'll managed it through good content again . It's really a lot of work Webmasters

almost 4 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.