Pull & Bear is a Spanish clothing retailer that although only opening a handful of stores so far in the UK, has more than 870 branches worldwide.

Its four year-old ecommerce site was brought to my attention a couple of weeks ago, when I wrote about Zara and its ‘unique’ onsite search tool on the blog.

It seems much like its Spanish cousin, with a similar attitude towards site search, breaking familiar ecommerce trends and presenting the user with something against their expectations.

Just to quickly remind ourselves, Zara operates a search tool where the content of the page completely disappears, then is replaced with dynamically loading search results as the user types.

The problem with this is in the unpleasant blankness that occurs before you begin typing as if something has gone wrong with the site. There is also a lack of filters or sorting tools and the full amount of search results is inaccessible from the default view.

It’s also impossible to close the search box, instead you have to navigate away by opening a separate menu. The nil results page is also just a blank page with little in the way of help.

I do however appreciate the originality of the tool, with results being served as large images with hoverable product info, and the automatic suggestions work very well.

Colbenson, the developers of Empathy Broker, which provides the tech behind both Zara and Pull & Bear’s search tools, revealed some interesting insight in their comments on the Zara article.

Chief customer officer Borja Santaolalla explains the logic behind Zara’s idiosyncratic approach to search. 

The search experience at Zara has been designed from a discovery perspective. That is, selling clothes is not a functional search, such as browsing a catalogue of electronics, search in fashion is about inspiration, it's about emotions and empathy.

Search as an inspiration tool, not necessarily as a discovery tool. This approach differs from what we would normally think of as best practice for ecommerce site search. 

However, there may be an argument to suggest that this type of search is beneficial to ecommerce sites where there is a single brand on offer, making it more immersive and enjoyable rather than constantly filtering through the multiple brands you’ve become accustomed to.

Angel Maldonado, the CEO at Colbenson, claims that people rarely use filters in single brand fashion. 

Less than 2% in our experience. From this small group 80% filter by gender (when there is gender) and nearly 20% colour/pattern/composition.

Whether you agree with this or not, onsite search is an interesting area of development, and any attempt to improve or innovate is to be applauded. It also seems that this ‘inspirational search’ tool is becoming more widely used. 

Which finally brings us to Pull & Bear and its search tool, which has a similar philosophy and function to Zara’s, but with many simple improvements. 

Instead of completely wiping the page of content when you click in the search box, a smaller flyover appears.

This is definitely an improvement as it doesn’t look like something’s gone wrong with the site. 

There is also the very simple addition of a close button, which is definitely lacking from Zara, and a way to toggle between how many results are served on the page.

Thus retaining practical usability whilst also keeping with the minimalist design.

The other important factor is that all the possible results are served in the flyover, not just a curated selection. These continue to load as you scroll down.

There is still a lack of filters though, with options available only surrounding design rather than price or colour. 

This goes back to the developer’s research that for single brand retailers extra filters are redundant. 

The other improvement is in the nil results pages. Here I am served with alternative products based on my search results.

And at least when I’m served absolutely no results, I can close the search box and navigate elsewhere.

So this is all very interesting. Again I’m not thoroughly satisfied that it completely works, but it’s an incremental improvement on other similar search tools. Please let me know what you think in the comments.

Christopher Ratcliff

Published 8 April, 2015 by Christopher Ratcliff

Christopher Ratcliff is the editor of Methods Unsound. He was the Deputy Editor of Econsultancy. You can follow him on Twitter or connect via Google+ and LinkedIn

686 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (3)

Steve Pannett

Steve Pannett, Senior Designer at three sixty

Designspiration (Google them for a link) use a similar search tool, but there's doesn't load content until you've finished your field input. A much nicer experience.

They also have a "search-by-colour" tool that I always thought fashion brands could benefit from. I agree with the developers that fashion searches are emotionally-driven. One of the few search function situations where the user doesn't actually know what they're looking for - until they see it.

almost 3 years ago

Avatar-blank-50x50

Chris Monkman, Web Developer at E-Dzine

Having worked on search tools before, I prefer to have a list giving me an idea of all posiblities to start with, then before I'm shown results allow me to whittle down options. So colours, styles, gender etc.

Once I know I've 30 jumpers to look at I'll hit the search button but If I've only typed in and clicked a few options to narrow things down I don't want to see a list just yet as I haven't asked for it.

But thats my $0.02 worth. (I also understand how difficult it is to get different ranges/product groups common search filters to play nicely with each other. So there's always that concern too)

almost 3 years ago

Rhys Bevan

Rhys Bevan, eCommerce Marketing Consultant at Something Different Wholesale

This may be something Zara has done in house, but Sooqr have been around a couple of years offering this search function:

http://www.sooqr.com/

Check out:

www.bulkpowders.co.uk
http://www.shore.co.uk/

almost 3 years ago

Comment
No-profile-pic
Save or Cancel
Daily_pulse_signup_wide

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.