The rise of influencer marketing doesn’t seem to be slowing, and it’s easy to see why.

It is the inevitable result of content and social coming together, and many brands have already seen some impressive results from this channel. 

But with it comes a number of challenges that many marketers are struggling to overcome, as outlined in our recent report, The Rise of Influencers, in collaboration with Fashion and Beauty Monitor. 

In this post I’m going to cover the top three challenges that marketers face when it comes to working with influencers, and how you can overcome them. 

1. Identifying the right influencer

This is the most commonly cited hurdle by the fashion and beauty marketers surveyed, with almost three quarters (73%) saying it was the biggest challenge in working with influencers.

Q: What has been the biggest challenge in working with influencers?

influencer marketing challenges

This could come down to an education gap, or it could be down to marketers simply lacking the right tools to effectively carry out influencer research. 

Brands are realising that it takes more than a quick Google or Twitter search to find relevant and valuable influencers. 

Frequently this task is outsourced to an agency that may or may not know any more about finding influencers than the brand does, so it becomes a convoluted process. A better approach is to bring talent in-house.

British beauty blogger Jane Cunningham says:

Employing a digital person who has no PR skills and, more importantly, no press contacts, is fairly pointless.

2. Measuring ROI 

The second biggest challenge is trying measure the return on investment (ROI), and therefore justifying spend on the channel. 

This issue certainly isn’t unique to influencer marketing. Brands and agencies alike have been struggling with ROI for many years, particularly when it comes to areas such as content and social. 

Perhaps instead of looking at direct financial return it would be more useful to consider the specific non-financial objectives of a campaign. 

79% of respondents cite ‘web traffic generated’ as their biggest indicator of success, for example, while 54% say ‘press coverage generated’. 

Q: How do you measure the success of a campaign where influencers have been used as part of the strategy?

influencer marketing stats

These metrics might not translate easily onto the balance sheet, but that doesn’t mean they’re not valuable.  

3. Getting their attention and engaging them

The third most-cited challenge is approaching and engaging influencers, with 59% of respondents struggling with this issue the most. 

Part of this problem probably stems from the increasing popularity of influencer marketing. As more brands want to get on board, demand for influencers goes up, which means brands have to work harder to win them over. 

Currently the influencers have the power. 

To have the best chance of engaging an influencer, brands need to not only offer a financial reward but also propose ideas that are relevant and of interest to the influencer’s audience. After all, the influencers themselves have a brand to protect. 

Tim Bax at iCrossing does, however, issue a stark warning to those influencers who might be at risk of alienating the brands that provide them with an income:

Influencers think that because they have some audience, they have the power. And of course they have some power, but they should be careful in how they use it.

Download the full report today for lots more insight around influencer marketing.

Jack Simpson

Published 23 February, 2016 by Jack Simpson

Jack Simpson is a Writer at Econsultancy. You can follow him on Twitter or connect via LinkedIn.

252 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (1)


Carlie Fall, Intern at FAPL

i. Great point - a brand’s growth depends on its ability to connect with its audience through personalized, highly engaging content. The power of user-generated content (UCG) means that a photo of someone wearing your brand is the most valuable type of photo asset. In fact, up to 44 percent of social media users have made a purchase due to a friend liking or posting about the brand on a social network. Factor in the 85 percent of millennials that purchase something after seeing it on social media, and it’s clear that positioning on the right social platform is crucial. Traditional social media doesn’t convert because it isn’t targeted. But, one brand owner solved the problem by creating a platform where brands can promote themselves through user-generated, shared looks. Once you upload your brand’s products, the app users can like, share and buy from the looks that you and your customers upload. It’s really the only solution out there that has true contextual commerce. It’s free to use, so you may want to try it out. Here’s the link:

about 2 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.