Programmatic continues to take over the digital advertising world, fueled in large part by advertisers who are enticed by the advantages programmatic offers, such as the ability to target audiences at scale.

But what about publishers? How do they feel about programmatic?

A survey conducted by ad tech firm Operative concluded that "when it comes to programmatic...publishers are from Mars, advertisers are from Venus."

While advertisers are increasingly spending through programmatic buys, because of the complex nature of the programmatic ecosystem, much of the money advertisers are spending is being gobbled up by middlemen and not finding its way to publishers.

In fact, Operative says that half of the publishers it polled said that programmatic generates less than 10% of their digital ad revenue.

According to Operative, there are a number of reasons that many publishers are struggling with programmatic...

When we asked publishers what limited their success, it became clear that they didn’t have the support and resources needed to succeed. The reasons for low programmatic CPMs were numerous, from lack of sales expertise to the complexity of dealing with conditional metrics for advertisers. Programmatic operations teams are also often dealing with lower quality inventory and unruly data sets, making it hard to justify higher prices.

But there's a potentially inconvenient truth that suggests publishers may struggle to profit from programmatic, even if they manage to address some of the addressable challenges they face. As Michael Hubbard of Media Two Interactive, a media planning and buying agency, commented...

It makes sense to me that their percent revenue is so low, [because] we use it for audience specific targeting - not publisher targeting, and that allows us to buy at extremely discounted rates off say a premium direct buy. That said - if all of our audience reports came back showing the users were on "x" web site, I guarantee you - I'd be buying more premium.

Put simply, advertisers can use programmatic to reach large numbers of members of specific audiences across many properties. Because they know which users are members of those audiences, and have some idea what they're worth, and the publishers don't, there is information asymmetry that leaves publishers at a disadvantage.

A threat to the programmatic ecosystem?

For now, advertisers clearly have the upper hand. After all, "he who has the gold makes the rules." But if over time publishers don't see tangible financial benefits from programmatic, it could pose a threat to the burgeoning but still-nascent programmatic ecosystem. 

Fortunately, there are signs that the market's evolution could make programmatic more equitable for publishers.

First, more and more premium publishers are creating private exchanges, and with research indicating that ads on premium properties deliver significantly higher brand lift, publishers with viable private exchanges have what appears to be a legitimate value proposition.

Second, technology advancements could benefit publishers. For example, server-side header bidding could change auction dynamics in ways that result in publishers realizing much greater revenue.

So while publishers might have reason to be skeptical about or frustrated with programmatic, those that are strategic and make smart moves could soon find that programmatic is a boon for them too.

For more on this topic, read:

Patricio Robles

Published 8 February, 2017 by Patricio Robles

Patricio Robles is a tech reporter at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter.

2642 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (3)

Alexander Levashov

Alexander Levashov, Director at Magenable

I would call it exaggeration that "Advertisers love programmatic". Just one quote from the recent P&G Chief Brand Officer:

“We serve ads to consumers through a non-transparent media supply chain with spotty compliance to common standards, unreliable measurement, hidden rebates and new inventions like bot and methbot fraud,”

over 1 year ago


Dan B, Digital Marketing Consultant at Chelios

I have to agree with Alexander. Advertisers may be spending through programmatic, but when ad fraud levels are so high with very few in the industry being prepared to even acknowledge it, let alone tackle it, loving programmatic is a definite exaggeration.

over 1 year ago


Matt Lovell, Head of Customer Data, Insight & Analytics at Eurostar International Ltd.

Interesting article.

I'm not sure it's a case of loving or hating programmatic. As flagged above, plenty of advertisers aren't that enthralled by programmatic and those who are should probably be second guessing themselves as far too much of the system is built on the wow factor of big numbers (of targeting on a large scale) but most campaigns will actually show little positive impact in terms of driving real awareness or sales.

On the publisher's front, there also needs to some responsibility taken as, as illustrated above, they still have plenty of advertising placements that are going perform poorly and ultimately are not of the same value (if any value) as their other more prominent positions. As a result, expecting to get a high yield from these is a fantasy and more effort needs to be made to grade ad positions in order for advertisers to be willing to pay more for the more effective of these.

That doesn't stop the fact that there is too much of a disconnect between what an advertiser pays and a publisher gets in return but there needs to be an element of pitching in and sorting your own business out too...

over 1 year ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.