The UK's online retailers experienced a rise in the number of bad orders last year, with an average of 1.9% of orders turning out to be fraudulent.

This is the headline finding from Cybersource's UK Online Fraud Report, which surveyed 200 etailers about the incidence of fraud and the challenges of fraud management. 

I've been asking the report's co-author Dr Akif Khan about the issues facing the UK's online retailers as they attempt to combat fraud.

Why did online fraud rise last year? 

Merchants are accepting more fraudulent orders, and part of the problem is that, while online sales volumes are growing, the investment in fraud management is not. 

For example, while 77% of merchants surveyed are expecting a rise in sales in 2011, 59% expect fraud management budgets to stay the same.

This suggests that retailers are unable to scale fraud management to match this expected growth. 

This could be that retailers have not been convinced by the business case for anti-fraud measures, or a tendency to put a fraud system in place and then leave it alone without the continual management that is needed to keep processes up to date. 

Is fraud more of a problem for smaller retailers? 

There are variations between different retailers. For example, large businesses expect to lose 1.2% of annual revenue to fraud, medium businesses 2.4% and small businesses 1.5%.

Small businesses generally have less efficient systems for detecting fraud which makes them more vulnerable. 

Larger retailers employed an average of seven different automated anti-fraud tools, while smaller retailers used just four. There is a similar trend for manual review: larger retailers are able to review more orders. 

Another issue is the payment solutions used by SMEs, which often come with basic security tools, though the retailer can tweak these systems to make them more secure. 

In contrast, larger businesses can develop systems in house or will above the budgets to purchase more advanced fraud management systems. 

Is the allocation of staff that 'own' fraud management another factor? 

Yes, in many businesses the fraud management role is often an add-on to someone else's job, which means they may not have enough time to devote to the issue. In larger firms, there tends to be a dedicated member of staff or a team in place to deal with fraud. 

Is the rejection of genuine orders a big problem? 

On average, 5% of transactions are rejected by anti-fraud measures, up slightly on last year. Many of these will be bad orders, but there are some good transactions being rejected. 

This can be a problem for retailers, as rejecting an order can be embarrassing for the customer, and will deter them from attempting to shop again from that retailer. 

The only solution is to keep fraud management systems and processes as up to date as possible. 

How effective are schemes like Verified by Visa at preventing fraud? 

3D Secure schemes, also known as payer authentication, such as Verified by Visa and MasterCard SecureCode continue to grow in popularity year-on-year.

These password protected identity verification services provide an additional layer of security for merchants, helping to mitigate the risk of online fraud. Payer authentication will not be completely effective if used in isolation but when combined with other fraud screening tools, it can help merchants minimise the cost of fraud to their organisation.

Are retailers satisfied with them, or do they deter some customers since they often have to leave checkout and fill in another form? 

Some retailers have expressed concern about whether 3D Secure can have a negative impact on customer experience, but these concerns are abating as more and more merchants implement the scheme.

The report shows that Verified by Visa is one of the most popular anti-fraud tools, with 73% of UK merchants having implemented it, and a further 10% planning to implement it in 2011. 

The key focus for merchants should be how they choose to integrate 3D Secure. The most successful implementations occur when merchants provide clear messaging and information to customers about the 3D Secure process so that customers are comfortable and therefore less likely to abandon the transaction at the checkout stage.

The fact that banks are becoming less dependent on ‘activation during shopping’ and are enrolling customers directly in 3D Secure also helps to reduce the number of potential steps during the shopping process, which should appeal to merchants.

The report finds that more companies are selling internationally. Presumably, this causes new problems for merchants?

Selling to international markets makes a lot of sense, it can insulate retailers against downturns in the domestic market, and provides a way to grow online sales. 

However, it does present new problems around fraud management. 

For one, manual review is more difficult, as knowledge of the local language and geography can be important when detecting fraudulent orders. 

Retailers need to have the right tools in place when they begin to sell abroad. 

In our survey, retailers rank the US as the third most likely source of fraud, behind Nigeria and Ghana. This is perhaps due to the sheer size of the US market, and also that high card penetration rates make it a target for fraudsters. 

How do rates of online fraud in the UK compare with the US? 

Fraud rates are higher than the US in this year's report. I think this can be explained by the fact that the average UK retailer is selling to more international markets than US merchants. 

This international expansion exposes retailers to more fraud, and helps to explain the discrepancy. 

I've heard complaints from online retailers that the police are ineffective when dealing with cases of fraud. How do you see this? 

I think it's very difficult for the police to investigate every case of fraud, so I think the approach of targeting the larger organisations behind online fraud is the right one. 

Also, everyone in the whole system needs to work to prevent fraud, including merchants, banks and card providers, companies offering payment solutions and the police. 

The report will be released on Tuesday 25 January. You can register in advance for a copy of the report on the Cybersource website.  

Graham Charlton

Published 18 January, 2011 by Graham Charlton

Graham Charlton is the former Editor-in-Chief at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter or connect via Linkedin or Google+

2565 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (5)

Avatar-blank-50x50

TrafficColeman

Graham..I see this stuff on CMNBC all the time about fraud..it such an big market that the police have no resources to fight it all..so it just get more out of control ..really you must just try to protect yourself..
"Black Seo Guy "Signing Off"

"Black Seo Guy "Signing Off"

about 7 years ago

Avatar-blank-50x50

Dallas Internet Marketing

Fraud is an on-going problem these days and it just gets bigger and bigger. As stated by "trafficcoleman", the police have limited resources to beat the problem.

about 7 years ago

Avatar-blank-50x50

Rich Brady

Can you still reset your Verified by Visa/3D Secure password with your DOB?

If so I stand by my opinion that it's an utter waste of time. If criminals have manged to get your card and addresss details, it's likely they know when you were born too.

about 7 years ago

Avatar-blank-50x50

aurelius tjin

I think it should be concerted effort on the government , the bank/credit card copanies, online merchants  and others who are involved in a transaction. There should be some kind of a system. Changs should be made such as, Credit Card companies should not ask obvious questions like birthdate and mother's maiden name. It should b a random question provided by the cardholder or some other changes.

about 7 years ago

Avatar-blank-50x50

shop refurbishment

Now time we took our business to online social media and from that we got the business and also frauds. frauds are creating problem for small retailers and also distributors i hope that fraud management getting way to out from this problem.

about 7 years ago

Comment
No-profile-pic
Save or Cancel
Daily_pulse_signup_wide

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.