Using social media in the financial services industry always challenged by the restrictions of internal risk and compliance processes and by external regulation.

How do you use social media in an environment where you can't promote your services, advise people or identify customers? And where you need archives of your communications, long approval processes and where information may become out of date?

For many the answer is to not use social media. But Morgan Stanley has recently announced a different approach - actually encouraging their advisers to engage people on Twitter and LinkedIn.

The use of social media in financial services is always fraught with challenges. From the regulatory issues which guide what can and cannot be said by brands, to internal risk and compliance processes which feel at odds with the real-time nature of much communication online.

Different businesses have dealt with this in different ways and most can be placed on a four-point spectrum:

  1. Do nothing: Some have stayed away from social media altogether.
  2. Listen but don't talk: Often quite detailed social media monitoring is in place across the business but no real engagement is taking place in response to this.

    The data from this listening may be being used in the business to getting a more rounded understanding of customers, the market, competitors and issues but it is not prompting engagement.

  3. Engage on a common interest: This is often a source of some great innovation in social media. Rather than engaging people about the brand, products or advice, firms have identified other, often more 'lifestyle' issues that they can engage their target audiences on.

    A good example would be the blogs on healthy eating and lifestyles from health insurers AXA PPP, or OPEN Forum from American Express which supports and engages small businesses about broader business and management issues.

  4. Engage on our products and expertise: This is an approach that many in the financial services industry are nervous of, and one that it is often discussed and debated within firms, with regulators and in the wider market.

    How do you engage people about your products and expertise in social media without falling foul of regulation or internal compliance issues?

For many financial services brands, they can get huge benefit from social media without having to engage people about your products and services.

If you are a general insurance firm you might get a lot of benefit from educating people about safer driving or how to look after their cars; you might also use social media to tell the market about exactly what you will cover and what you won't, helping to reduce dissatisfaction when people do have to make claims.

If you provide business banking, you might create a peer-to-peer support and mentoring community so that you are seen by your customers (and potentially your targets) as the single place for their business support, so they get banking services from you, as well as wider business support.

For many there are huge opportunities in social media without needing to talk about or 'promote' your products, services and expertise. However, there are ways of doing this and Morgan Stanley has announced a social media strategy that does that.

From June, Morgan Stanley will launch a pilot programme allowing 600 of its financial advisers to market themselves and to share their ideas and expertise through social media - notably through Twitter and LinkedIn.

If this is a success, the programme will be rolled-out to the firm's 17,800 employees by the end of the year. This is in part a great way for the firm to show that is embracing social media and new channels of communication.

Indeed, as Andy Saperstein who runs the brokerage's US operations said of the programme:

This will be a significant competitive advantage. We are the first major wealth-management firm to announce a vendor solution for our advisers to use key social-networking sites to market themselves and share the firm’s intellectual content.

But as well as this kind of first-mover advantage, the firm is acknowledging that the ways people communicate has changed and that clients, and their own advisers are asking for engagement through these new channels. There may even be (already or a risk of) these advisers engaging in social media anyway.

What has made Morgan Stanley's move possible is the growing emergence of social media management tools. It will be using one that is specifically built for compliance.

All interactions are archived and specific tweets and comments in LinkedIn may be quarantined for approval, with the internal compliance workflows built into the system.

Finally, some features are disabled. For instance, brokers will not be able to 'recommend' themselves or others in LinkedIn.

The Morgan Stanley experiment is about more than just being seen as a first-mover in social media for the industry. It is using social media management tools to create a safe and more controlled experience, and an environment for brokers to experiment with and use social media as part of their role and within the constrictions that are placed on them.

What will be interesting to observe is how these channels are actually used; how many of the tweets and comments will actually be about products, services and expertise, and how many of them will be more about pointing to interesting content, building brands online for the brokers and really engaging with people on common topics of interest.

My suspicion is that it will be more about the latter than the former, and that fewer issues than we expect will be subject to regulatory restrictions.

In the UK, the FSA guidelines on 'new media' assume that the main use of social media will be as another marketing channel. In reality, I suspect that firms and individuals in financial services are more likely to be using them to engage and have dialogue with people on common areas of interest, sharing and pointing to interesting comment that others have written, and building relationships online.

There is probably less to worry about than we think we might think.

Matt Rhodes

Published 31 May, 2011 by Matt Rhodes

Matt Rhodes is Client Services Director at FreshNetworks and contributor to Econsultancy. 

9 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (7)

Save or Cancel


It will be ver interesting to see how morgan stanley handle this.

Compliance can be a problem when trying to tackle engaging with customers in the instant world of social media. I would like to see how quick turn around time will be for dealing with queries or adivce!

about 7 years ago


Tom Huxtable, CRO at EngageSciences

Citibank in the US have been dong some interesting things with social media. Firstly they have been actively engaging with people on social channels and have a prominent voice.

Secondly they have been embracing social media marketing. Such as launching a promotion on Facebook and Twitter where people can win free Christmas shopping on their Citibank credit card as an incentive to drive the social spread of a credit card offer.

I do hope the FSA does not overly encumber UK financial services institutions from properly engaging on social channels for support, marketing and other purposes. Or will we be shown the way by the US again before attitudes to change this side of the pond?
When UK Financial Institutions are ready to develop social media marketing strategies beyond their sponsorhsip programs we will be waiting!

about 7 years ago

Remiz Rahnas

Remiz Rahnas, Head of Production at WebCastle Media Pvt LTD

What I hate about Big Company social media is they respond too late. Seriously, can you imagine if ICICI bank send you back a reply for your tweet after a week? I got one!
Same with Seagate, when I lost some data on it, they responded 3 days after saying contact support center.

Amazing experience I had with is Airtel, the leading mobile service provider in India. They responded in less than five minutes and head office called me on phone within 30 minutes. And that too two times when I had issues.

Key is, reply now or never mind. Social media is not your dady's support ticket. It should be fast.

about 7 years ago


Looking for Representatives

Very interesting!

about 7 years ago


The Social Bank

Great to see another company finally making a social media move in the financial industry.

I do wonder if Morgan Stanley is educating the pilot group on how to effectively use social media though. Don't just turn it on and say good luck with that and let's see what happens.

I agree that all the worry on regulations and compliance is probably just that, worry. Don't get me wrong they do need to be careful but the engaging conversations will be about connecting and enhancing experience, not exposing personal information.

about 7 years ago


David Cho

Thanks for the article. I'll say that you're the first person to put in writing that direct advertising is NOT the main driver for social media. It's also about positioning your brand/company as an expert and thought leader.

about 7 years ago



Consider… YOU!In all time before now and in all time to come, there has never been and will never be anyone just like you. You are unique in the entire history and future of the universe. Wow! Stop and think about that. You're better than one in a million, or a billion, or a gazillion…

about 7 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.