With 750m users and growing, Facebook is one of the most attractive platforms for brand advertisers to reach consumers.

But there's a problem: while it may be capturing more and more dollars from major brand advertisers, the efficacy of advertising on Facebook is still questionable.

If Facebook isn't able to change that, it will obviously face challenges long-term.

In an effort to create ad offerings that satisfy its advertisers, the world's largest social network turned to some of the agencies it works with. "What do you want?" the company asked.

Out of 100 ideas submitted by the agencies for ad formats that would take advantage of Facebook's characteristics, Facebook selected one proposed by Leo Burnett. The ad format: a "Comment" ad. Fast Company's E.B. Boyd explains:

The new unit is called the “Comment” ad. It will appear in the right-hand column, like other ads. But it will be formatted like a conversation (or, as Facebook calls them, “a story”). The brand will make a statement or pose a question, and below that will be a comment box where the user can enter a response.

If the user does enter a response, the conversation then appears in the user’s News Feed, where the brand starts to reap “earned” impressions among that user’s friends. And if some of the user’s friends comment themselves, those comments can be turned into Sponsored Stories.

As Boyd suggests, "it’s the ad that keeps on giving" -- at least in theory.

Needless to say, Facebook is wise to take advantage of its enviable position to work with major agencies on new ad formats. After all, it's easy to sell an ad unit that advertisers themselves created.

But will it work?

Developing an ad format that sells is not the same thing as developing an ad format that works. Brand advertisers love advertising; consumers generally don't.

While the Comment ad format may seem like a great way to create brand-consumer 'conversations', it assumes that consumers want to talk about ads.

In some cases, of course, they do. Certain ads organically produce a lot of buzz, both good and bad. But therein lies the problem: many of the advertising campaigns that go 'viral' don't necessarily do the best job at selling a brand and its products and services. In many cases, beyond a short-term spike in visibility, there's little measurable impact.

Yet increasingly, advertisers are shooting for that short-term spike in visibility, and the best way brands to create catchy (and sometimes wacky) ad campaigns that aren't really aligned with their brand's positioning in the market.

Conceivably, ad formats like the one Leo Burnett has created for Facebook will only encourage brand advertisers to focus more on creating content than creating effective branding, which it's easy to forget are not the same thing.

After all, if you expect Facebook users, who are more likely to click on ads with a picture containing beer, to engage with the Comment ads, you're probably going to need to focus on content more than anything else. And that may not be such a good thing for brands not in the content business.

Patricio Robles

Published 27 June, 2011 by Patricio Robles

Patricio Robles is a tech reporter at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter.

2645 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (2)

Aggelos Taplatzidis

Aggelos Taplatzidis, Consultant, Web solutions at Squiz UK

I dont know if that idea will actually work and nobody can really tell with certainty. But it is certainly in par with the notion of social media so it will definitely be better than the static irrelevant ads we currently encounter.

Angelos Taplatzidis

about 7 years ago

Peter Gould

Peter Gould, Senior PPC Analyst at Epiphany

I'd be intrigued to find out how advertisers go about regulating these comments - will it have to be done manually, or does Facebook have an algorithm that can detect Positive v. Negative sentiment in comments?

The last thing you'd want as an advertiser is have somebody comment "Don't buy Product X.. it's rubbish!" and then that show as a branded Sponsored Story ad to other users automatically.

Does anybody have an insight on how this will work? Manually by the advertiser hand-picking good comments, or automatically by Facebook?

about 7 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.