Recently, mobile startup Path was caught 'stealing' its users' address books without their permission. Not surprisingly, this created a firestorm in the tech blogosphere.

In response, Path CEO Dave Morin, a former Facebook employee, issued an apology.

"We made a mistake," he wrote. "We believe you should have control when it comes to sharing your personal information. We also believe that actions speak louder than words. So, as a clear signal of our commitment to your privacy, we’ve deleted the entire collection of user uploaded contact information from our servers. Your trust matters to us and we want you to feel completely in control of your information on Path."

This sounded good, and for some, Morin's note was a case study in how to issue an effective apology.

But others weren't as impressed. Path had to have known what it was doing, they argued, and its theft of users' address books was a clear violation of Apple's policies. The apology was too little, too late for the detractors.

Unfortunately, the debate over Path's actions has devolved into a childish argument between conflicted Path 'investors' who also fashion themselves 'journalists' and 'journalists' who are angry that they haven't been able to cash in on their supposed influence. This junior high school-style argument, complete with cursing and name-calling, distracts from the real issue: the fact that Path was engaging in behavior that is described, at best, as highly-questionable.

When it comes to the matter of whether the company's apology was enough, Path's supporters (conflicted and otherwise) suggest that when a company acts opaquely and unethically, all can be made well by pretending to be transparent and ethical after the fact. The truth, however, is that it's not that easy.

Not all apologies are created equal, and the difference between them starts at what you're apologizing for. Path investor and self-described 'unpaid blogger' Michael Arrington says "The truth is that startups are always in a hurry and always make mistakes," but let's be honest here: deciding to build functionality that uploads your users' address books to your server without their permission is not a mistake resulting from haste; it's a mistake resulting from a lack of integrity.

If your ethical IQ is too low to immediately recognize that uploading and storing your users' address book without their permission isn't an ethical business practice, chances are you have bigger problems than writing an apology that sounds authentic. The same applies to startups whose founders haven't figured out that stealing designs (and hotlinking no less) is not adult behavior.

There lesson here for startups is not "apologize quickly when you make mistakes", but rather "try not to make mistakes for which apologies are demanded." Yes, that's a high standard, but the reality is that for most companies, the path to success is not paved with high-profile apologies. Sure, there are some exceptions, like Facebook, and perhaps Path will manage to find a moral compass before the VC well runs dry and it has to become a self-sustaining business (I personally won't be holding my breath), but companies hoping to build something that's viable over the long haul should do everything possible to ensure that well-written apologies don't become a product line.

Patricio Robles

Published 14 February, 2012 by Patricio Robles

Patricio Robles is a tech reporter at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter.

2647 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (1)

Carlos Pacheco

Carlos Pacheco, SEM Strategist at Temple Street Productions

Obviously the issue with Path is not something to be taken lightly but what bugs me about this issue is how Path is getting the brunt of the bad PR when many very popular apps do exactly the same, or did.
I've often heard the motto from entrepreneurs that "asking forgiveness is easier than asking for permission" I'm thinking and hoping that this "rule" might not be applied for much longer.

over 6 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.