Does Jeff Bezos know about this?Statsaholic, the Alexa-powered traffic tool formerly known as Alexaholic, is being systematically crushed by Amazon in a move that is going to create a wave of negative PR for the online retail giant.

Earlier this month Amazon sent a legal warning that forced Alexaholic to drop the Alexa from its name. Fair enough – brands have to look after their trademarks. But now it is preventing Statsaholic from using its API at all.

This is bad news, and sends out a highly ridiculous message to current and prospective users of Amazon Web Services. The message is this: “If you are successful, we can close you down.”

None of this is in the spirit of web services, and it doesn’t tally with the company’s visionary progress in this space over the past five years, nor some of the more recent statements made by CEO Jeff Bezos.

Amazon Web Services is used by more than 200,000 web developers, all of whom are helping to fuel the Amazon fire, by creating spin-off sites like mashups and affiliate stores.

Some of these sites are more valuable to Amazon than others. And now, we can say for sure that some are seen as threats, although perhaps not without reason. Is it true that I stopped using Alexa on the day I first used Alexaholic? Yes, yes it is.

I’m sure that this latest move by Amazon seems to be some extension of the legal posturing with regards to its trademark, but I can’t see what good can come of this. Alexaholic is now known as Statsaholic, so what does it have to gain from trying to kill the site completely?

Keyword = ‘trying’
Here’s the thing: Statsaholic will not die. You know that saying about ‘what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger’? It looks like this is what will become of Statsaholic, according to founder Ron Hornbaker:

“Compete and Quantcast have shown their support of Statsaholic by agreeing to have their traffic graphs displayed here, so look for those in the very near future. Alexa is not without competition in the comparative web metrics space, and if they bully around developers like me, there will be more progressive-minded companies to take their place.”

Amazon appears to have fired a volley of Katyusha rockets into its foot. And it could get worse; it could become an irreversible situation for the company, certainly as far as Alexa and Statsaholic is concerned.

If Ron ropes in Hitwise, comScore and Nielsen/NetRatings, as well as Compete and Quantcast, he can aggregate the various data sources out there, to – theoretically - improve results. Most internet marketers will rightly point out that none of these services are 100% accurate, but Alexa is widely considered to be less accurate than most.

My bet is that this will blow over by the end of the week. I’ll be amazed if it doesn’t, and I’ll be equally amazed if Jeff Bezos knows anything about this, which is surely an exercise in missing the point.

Chris Lake

Published 26 March, 2007 by Chris Lake

Chris Lake is CEO at EmpiricalProof, and former Director of Content at Econsultancy. Follow him on Twitter, Google+ or connect via Linkedin.

582 more posts from this author

You might be interested in

Comments (2)



Wow, way to get it wrong Chris. Alexaholic / Statsaholic doesn't use Alexa's API for those fancy graphs. The graphs are simply taken from the Alexa site and framed. I'd call that piracy. Further, A/S could use a legitimate API for traffic history ( but he doesn't.

Thought experiment. I'm going to create a site called e-consultancy-aholic. I'll take your logo and "mash" it. Then for my main feature, I'll take images from your site... but I won't just copy them, I'll have your server actually serve those images. Now mix in a few ads and voila! I have a business.

Now, would you defend that?

over 11 years ago

Chris Lake

Chris Lake, CEO at Empirical Proof

Ouch. That wasn't my understanding of the situation based on what I'd read over at Statsaholic, but if it isn't using APIs then my article is baseless. I'll hold my hands up to that...

I'll also reverse my position on this. APIs = good. Scraping = bad. If Ron is relying on the latter to power his site then I too would put a stop to it.


over 11 years ago

Save or Cancel

Enjoying this article?

Get more just like this, delivered to your inbox.

Keep up to date with the latest analysis, inspiration and learning from the Econsultancy blog with our free Digital Pulse newsletter. You will receive a hand-picked digest of the latest and greatest articles, as well as snippets of new market data, best practice guides and trends research.