2009 has seen a lot of changes in the search market, the recent introduction of real time search for one, so I’ve been asking some of the UK’s search experts about the most significant events of 2009, and their predictions for next year…

What have been the most significant issues for search in 2009?

Ciaran Norris, Head of Social Media at Mindshare:

Twitter’s tip into the mainstream, and the subsequent rush towards
real-time search, has seen social and search collide like never
before. Whilst I’m not convinced that the current Google/Twitter interface
will stay, the thought behind it is the interesting thing.

On another
note, the struggle by media companies to work out whether or not they
want to be searchable anymore could have a profound impact on content
over the coming years.

Will Critchlow, Director of Distilled:

I think with hindsight we will say that the increase in personalisation
(and particularly Google’s roll-out of personalisation even to
non-signed-in users) will be viewed as the most significant event. It’s
really the end of the ‘#1 ranking’ and it opens up an amazing array of
new marketing tactics, especially for big brands.

Andrew Girdwood, Head of Search at Bigmouthmedia:

It’s hard not to talk about Bing when we examine what
significant search events occurred in 2009. Even if you’re not a fan of Bing,
even if you think Google will wipe the floor with Bing you would be wrong to
suggest that Bing’s not had a visible influence on Google. If it was not for
Bing we would likely still be waiting for Google to push its own real-time
search and Twitter integration.

One of the areas search is growing is around personal
identity. Google’s started to automatically personalise web search results.
This is huge.  Google and Facebook have been battling it out with competing
“Connection” services; or universal logins. These are a corner stone to both
companies’ social media and personal targeting ambitions.

Kevin Gibbons, Director of Search at SEOptimise:

Personally from a UK search perspective I think one of the
biggest issues in 2009 was Google’s broken
UK search results
. It’s very rare that an algorithm update
from Google reduces the relevancy or quality of search results,
especially over such widespread results and for a long period of time.

This has generated a lot of attention and caused many headaches for UK
SEOs trying to figure out why their sites/clients are listed behind US
and Australian sites when searching in Google UK!

Despite the changes Google have been rolling out recently, I don’t think you can look past the Microsoft/Yahoo deal as the most significant event of
the year. A realistic competitor to Google has been long-overdue,
especially in the UK where they have such a dominant market share.
Potentially the deal could make a significant impact to how advertisers
allocate their online advertising budgets. So once Bing and adCenter
replace Yahoo search it’s likely online marketers will be taking Bing
far more seriously for organic and paid search strategies.

Shane Quigley, CEO at Epiphany:

well as Bing’s inclusion of Twitter search capability and Google’s
wide-scale rollout of universal search, 2009 has shown us that social
factors will play a major role in 2010.

It is
clear to me that the Vince update aimed at identifying brands was also
a step towards monitoring social barometers to measure popularity.
Things like tweets,
brand mentions, links, images, videos and product reviews will all play
a part in Googles future algorithm calculations.

What will be the major search trends in 2010?

Ciaran Norris:

I think that next year will see the continued convergence of
technologies and channels, particularly TV, mobile, search &
social. The real-time search movement will continue in some way, shape
or form, though the engines still need to perfect ranking &

The continued rise of mobile web, pulling in GPS &
augmented reality, means that people will expect geo-results. And as TV
gets webbed up (Yahoo TV Widgets etc…) people searching and
chatting on and around shows will become a new way of reaching
people, or at least learning about what they want.

Will Critchlow:

I’m going to go out on a limb here and say that I think 2010 will see
the beginnings of a backlash against Google. There have been murmurings
for some time among the tech community about their all-pervading
presence, ambition to gather everyone’s data for their own marketing
purposes and effective monopoly.

It wouldn’t surprise me to see them
take a step too far and face political push-back over their expansion
into the desktop and mobile phone markets. If they use market power in
one arena to manipulate another, that’s classic monopolistic behaviour. Personally, I’d love to see Bing gain some market share. I think a strong competitor would ultimately benefit everyone.

Andrew Girdwood:

We’ll see continued improvements in visual search. Google
Goggles is one example but we’ll also see mobile applications that effect an
augmented reality that combine search and location-aware search. These will let
searchers show the engines what they want help with and get back results.

Privacy will also be a hot issue in 2010. Targeting becomes
ever more important to companies and yet the ability not to be targeted becomes
ever more important to people. It seems impossible that we’ll avoid tension on
this front.

Of particular interest will be looking beyond the last
click. DoubleClick offers Click Path Analysis. Atlas offers User Engagement
Mapping. There will be other offerings from alternative technology providers
who wish to remain competitive against these search engine owned offerings.
2010 will see sites wrestle with tagging and tracking but invest in the
required technology in 2010 with the ambition of not having to return to this
fight for a while.

As real-time search helps surface social media sites in the
blink of an eye the aspects of ‘search’, ‘marketing’, ‘public relations’ and
even ‘customer care’ will all get drawn together. We’ll see different types of
agencies pitching against one another for the first time. We’ll see corporate
departments defending their turf and fighting for budget against their
colleagues across the hall.

Kevin Gibbons:

page speed is going to have an influence over organic rankings
in 2010 and is likely to have a strong impact on designers/developers
as well as SEO’s. At the moment there are unanswered questions, such as
how heavily will slow sites be penalised? Will fast sites be boosted in
the search engines? So it will be interesting to see the impact this

Now that the Microsoft/Yahoo deal is now all tied-up, advertisers
will need to start thinking seriously about Bing’s more sizeable market
share and start to prepare for when this is integrated with Yahoo

Google Wave has been slowly rolled out to
users so far during 2009, this has a lot of potential which is unlikely
to be truly realised until it reaches a greater audience. There’s a lot of
uncertainly about how popular Google Wave will become at the moment, so
it will be very interesting to see if this can really take off in 2010.
I’m sure they’ll be new social media sites coming onto the scene too,
along with developments to many of the current top social media sites; Twitter business accounts, for example, will be a good one to look out

    Shane Quigley:

    Rumoured for a while, and discovered live on the web by a clever person over at Gizmodo,
    there is a new Google Interface on the way for 2010. Being referred to
    as the three panel layout this change will mean it will become
    increasing important to rank highly in Image, Video and other search
    results as Google gives more prominence to these sections within its

    Real Time search has huge implications in terms of brand protection, what results
    people will click, as well as creating new opportunities to rank. Google
    also announced earlier this month that everyone’s search results are
    now being personalised (to an extent) based on your previous search
    behaviour, regardless of whether you’re logged in or not. Are the days
    of the ranking report now truly numbered?

    Changes will come thick and fast as Google look to hold market
    share and the new Caffeine architecture should give them the processing
    power to do a lot more with their search application.